It's claimed that North Yorkshire's housing crisis could be resolved without controversial new targets if 40,000 homes already granted planning permission or allocated land were actually built.
Housing waiting lists and controversial government targets could become a thing of the past if developers built the tens of thousands of homes already approved across the county.
Around 40,000 new properties already have planning permission or sit on allocated land in North Yorkshire.
Government housing targets currently demand more than 4,000 new homes a year to be built in the region. The struggle to demonstrate a five-year housing land supply has shifted the balance in favour of developers, often leading to building on sites outside established boundaries.
This push for development regularly prompts objections from communities concerned about the severe impact on local infrastructure and the changing character of their towns and villages.
North Yorkshire Council's executive member for housing, Councillor Simon Myers, explained the sheer scale of the unbuilt backlog:
"There are all 29,000 existing planning consents for houses in North Yorkshire, and there are another, I think, 12,000 sites identified in the existing local plans where nobody's applied for planning permission yet.
So, if they were all built out, we'd have 40,000 new houses in North Yorkshire. I wouldn't be worrying about housing waiting lists, and we wouldn't be worrying about the new imposed housing targets that the government has forced on us."
The vast number of unbuilt homes has sparked immense frustration as new national planning rules strip elected representatives of their power to decide on smaller local developments.
The new National Scheme of Delegation for Planning, which came into force on the 31st of October, shifts decision-making for certain applications away from elected councillors and hands it to professional planning officers.
It's claimed that small rural communities will face the biggest real-world impact. Applications for ten or fewer houses will no longer automatically go before a planning committee, removing a vital route for residents to make public representations.
Councillor Simon Myers warned that the loss of democratic oversight stems from a belief that local councillors stand in the way of development:
"It will be of no comfort to the residents of North Yorkshire, who will now find that in their small villages, when an application for 10 or less houses comes forward, there is no route for that to be considered by elected members and for them to make public representations about it.
It's important that public realize that we have no power to change this national schema delegation. It's not something we want."
The sweeping changes will also affect planning applications submitted by the council itself, as well as those from elected members or council officers.
Previously, these specific applications automatically went to planning committees to ensure complete transparency and maintain public confidence in the planning system. Under the new rules, planning officers may determine them behind closed doors unless a nominated councillor and officer agree that a public committee review is necessary.
Councillor Simon Myers expressed deep concern over the removal of this transparent process:
"Predecessor councils and the new North Yorkshire Council, required that any applications by the council itself, by elected members or by officers were automatically referred to planning committees.
That is so that the public could see openly that the process was being followed. That there was no possibility of deals being done behind closed doors or the slurs that are sometimes given by those who dislike us to say that we're all scratching each other's backs.
So there was a transparent and clear process by which these things were aired in public and that is now removed by this government who perhaps don't see the benefit of that."
Decisions made by planning committees that breach the new regulations could face judicial review and potentially be overturned in court.
The mandatory changes had to be incorporated into the local constitution by the end of October, with a full report due to go before councillors in November.


Emergency Services Blackout Threatens TV Heartbeat Village During Power Cuts
Brave Fundraisers Invited To Register For Scarborough's 2027 New Year's Day Dip
Scarborough's Alpamare Waterpark Returns to Council Control Ahead of Sale
Northern England's Largest Outdoor Ice Rink Returns For Twenty-First Season
Whitby Christmas Festival Declared Huge Success
Campaigners Form Giant 400 On Scarborough Beach For Sea Pool Fundraiser
Hornsea Volunteers Receive Highest Honour With King's Award For Voluntary Service
MP Confident That Scarborough Regeneration Will Go Ahead
East Yorkshire Village of Skipsea Named Booking.com's Top Trending UK Destination for 2027
Outcome Rates For Sexual Offences In North Yorkshire Hit National High
Rough Sleepers In North Yorkshire To Be Offered Route Off Streets By Christmas
Chinese Government Delegation Visits Scarborough to Inspect Shellfish Exports






