The Scarborough and Whitby Green Party has strongly criticised Water Minister Emma Hardy's response to Yorkshire Water's pollution plans, demanding an end to water privatisation amid ongoing concerns over local bathing water quality.
The chair of the local Green Party has hit out at the water minister’s ‘credulous attitude’ following a visit to North Yorkshire.
The Scarborough and Whitby Green Party has criticised the “cosy relationship between politicians and polluters” following the recent visit of Water Minister Emma Hardy to the resort as part of a National Water Tour “to look at where customer bill money has been spent on improving water and reducing pollution right around the country”.
On a visit last week, the water minister said she had “been to visit some of the assets that have been upgraded, talking to Yorkshire Water about their improvement plans, so that we can see a constant improvement and reduction in the number of pollution incidents, so more people can enjoy the beach safely.”
Issues with Scarborough’s bathing water quality have continued to persist and last year’s ratings saw the South Bay still classed as ‘poor’ and the North Bay’s bathing water quality classed as ‘sufficient’.
Yasmin Khan, chair of Scarborough and Whitby Green Party, said:
“The minister is correct that water regulation has failed, so it’s baffling that she is reassured by the latest promises from Yorkshire Water.
“This is the same private company that has paid out £7.6 billion to shareholders while filling our waterways with sewage.”
Yorkshire Water has said it is set to deliver its largest ever environmental investment between 2025 and 2030, with £8.3 billion to be spent across the region to improve services and upgrade infrastructure.
The company spent £2.85 million upgrading the Wheatcroft combined sewer outfall, which discharges a mix of rainwater and sewage into the bay during heavy rain.
Ms Khan told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS):
“The minister’s credulous attitude sadly reflects the type of cosy relationship between politicians and polluters that has led to the mess we’re in now, and it stinks.
”We urgently need to end the decades-long experiment with privatisation and bring water back into public ownership, so the quality of our water is no longer determined by shareholders & CEOs.”
An extraordinary meeting of the Scarborough and Whitby Area Committee will be held on Monday, March 23, to discuss water quality in the town.
Water Minister, Ms Hardy said:
“One of the projects I’ve seen is is a £3 million investment in a storm tank and one of the things that they’re doing is collecting some of the storm overflow that would have been discharged to sea, holding it in tanks, waiting for drier days to come, where it can then enter the system and be treated safely.”
Asked if regulation of the water industry had failed in past years, she told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS):
“Absolutely, when we came into government, it was quite clear that the regulation had failed.”
Alison Hume, Labour MP for Scarborough and Whitby, said:
“The water quality ratings will be reviewed in November this year and of course, that will impact the summer season.
“I know that due to the investment that McCain’s have made in their sewage plant of around £23 million, the investment in the overflow that Yorkshire Water has made, the water quality is actually improving.
She said:
“But the official designation doesn’t come until November, and I’m going to be asking the government whether there’s any way that we can reassure visitors and residents and people going into the water, that it is actually cleaner than the poor classification suggests it is.”
Adam Ashman, head of strategic planning at Yorkshire Water, said he understood the concern of residents who have said that not enough is being done fast enough to address the poor water quality.
Mr Ashman said:
“A huge amount of focus is needed to deliver the improvements that are required, and from where I sit, I see people working incredibly hard to deliver a huge amount of investment that will change the water quality in the town”.
Related Stories
-
12 Mar 2026 - There is 'more to do' to improve water quality in a much-loved North Yorkshire resort, according to a Government minister.
New Exhibition Explores The Nostalgic History Of Scarborough's Mr. Marvel's Amusement Park
Approval Granted For New 24-Hour Gym And Greggs In Scarborough
Scarborough's Alpamare Waterpark Could Have New Owner by Autumn
RNLI Launches Float To Live Campaign Ahead Of Busy Summer
RNLI Lifeguards Return to Redcar and Saltburn Beaches for the Summer Season
Yorkshire Water Reservoirs In Healthy Position Ahead Of Warm Bank Holiday Weekend
Mixed Reactions To Sir Robert Goodwill's Appointment As Yorkshire Bathing Water Partnership Chair
Smiley and Sad Face Speed Signs Set to Remain Banned in North Yorkshire
No Date For Delayed Opening Of Scarborough NHS Diagnostics Centre
Whitby Town Sign Promising Defender Stan Hewitt Following Bridlington Town Departure
New Owner Sought For Scarborough's Alpamare Water Park
No Redundancies Expected As Bridlington Care Unit Staff To Be Redeployed Across Local NHS
