On Air Now

The Retro Coast

2:00pm - 3:00pm

  • 01723 336444

Now Playing

Kim Wilde

Four Letter Word

Download

NHS reported to police after 'butcher surgeon' evidence destroyed

Monday, 22 December 2025 01:25

By Connor Gillies, Scotland correspondent

A woman who had the wrong body part removed by her surgeon is lodging a police complaint after the NHS destroyed vital evidence needed for a public inquiry.

Disgraced Dr Sam Eljamel was head of neurosurgery at NHS Tayside in Dundee from 1995 until his suspension in 2013, when a series of allegations emerged that he had harmed dozens of patients.

Police are examining around 200 complaints involving claims that Eljamel carried out life-changing "botched" brain and spinal operations.

Sky News previously heard some people left paralysed are requiring 24/7 care.

NHS orders staff to stop shredding

A judge-led public inquiry is currently under way in Scotland, and NHS Tayside was given a formal "do not destroy" notice to protect vital evidence for the hearings.

It emerged in November that health bosses got rid of 40 hard copy theatre logbooks linked to the disgraced surgeon's operations.

On Friday, NHS Tayside issued an all-staff email with an order to stop shredding documents.

Eljamel is now thought to be operating at hospitals in his native Libya.

Sky News contacted the hospital in Misrata, Libya, where an employee confirmed he works almost every day. They declined our request to speak directly to him.

Campaigners call in police

Jules Rose was Eljamel's final patient in the UK before he was suspended in 2013.

Her tear duct was removed instead of her brain tumour. She subsequently sued the NHS and won.

Ms Rose, now a leading campaigner in the fight for justice, is lodging a police complaint against NHS Tayside over the destruction of the theatre logbooks.

The former marathon runner, who brands Eljamel a "butcher", is set to file a dossier with detectives in Dundee on Monday afternoon.

An excerpt of the complaint, seen by Sky News, states "the materials destroyed were capable of identifying witnesses, corroborating criminal conduct and testing the integrity of patient records".

The document suggests the shredding happened "shortly before Police Scotland sought access to these same records" as part of their ongoing investigation.

Read more from Sky News:
Shipyard delays delivery of ferry
Swinney condemns alleged bugging
Parents of sextortion victim sue Meta

NHS Tayside told Sky News the staff who destroyed the logbooks were "not aware of the connection" between Eljamel and the documents.

A spokeswoman confirmed the theatre information had been requested by police, who were later informed it had been shredded by mistake.

Sky News

(c) Sky News 2025: NHS reported to police after 'butcher surgeon' evidence destroyed

Did you find this article useful?

This is the Coast is committed to providing a daily local news service for the Yorkshire Coast. We are a small locally owned and operated business which employs professional journalists and reporters. We do not receive any public funding or grants and we are entirely funded by our local commercial operations. We enjoy fabulous support from local businesses who work with us on their advertising and marketing campaigns, but the cost of providing high quality, well researched, fact checked local news coverage is significant.

If you appreciate what This is the Coast does, and would like to help support our journalism, please consider supporting us on a monthly basis today.

A small contribution from all our readers would really help support independent journalism for the Yorkshire Coast.

More from National News

Follow Us

Get Our Apps

Our Apps are now available for iOS, Android and Smart Speakers.

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play
  • Just ask Amazon Alexa
  • Available on Roku

Today's Weather

  • Scarborough

    Medium-level cloud

    High: 9°C | Low: 6°C

  • Filey

    Medium-level cloud

    High: 10°C | Low: 7°C

  • Whitby

    Low-level cloud

    High: 9°C | Low: 7°C

  • Bridlington

    Medium-level cloud

    High: 9°C | Low: 7°C

  • Hornsea

    Sunny intervals

    High: 9°C | Low: 7°C

  • Driffield

    Medium-level cloud

    High: 9°C | Low: 6°C

News