A significant shift in how the Yorkshire Coast celebrates the festive season has sparked a heated debate within North Yorkshire Council, as the authority moves to end the free provision of Christmas trees and hanging baskets in Scarborough and Harrogate.
The decision aims to bring these areas into line with the rest of the county, including Whitby and Filey, where local town and parish councils already carry the financial responsibility for their own illuminations.
The move has highlighted a stark divide between those who view the funding as an outdated "two-tier system" and those who fear it damages civic pride for a negligible saving. For Scarborough, the transition is particularly sharp, as the local Town Council's 2026/27 budget has already come under fire for allocating £70,000 for Christmas lights while simultaneously reducing community grants by 62 per cent.
At a meeting of North Yorkshire Council, Knaresborough Liberal Democrat Councillor Matt Walker questioned the logic of the cuts, pointing to the council's own equality assessment which suggests the move may impact civic pride. During a budget meeting, he expressed his concerns in full:
"Across the former Harrogate and Scarborough districts, including Scarborough, Whitby, and Filey, the council is ending the free provision of Christmas trees and hanging baskets to save just 27,000 in a £650 million budget.
We know what this means. No Christmas trees or towns and parish councils will have to pick up the bill.
This budget claims to have no money for festive trees. Yet, there's a capital outlay of 1.1 million to upgrade the Filey Brigg caravan and camping site. So I ask when did glamping pods become the higher priority?"
In response to these concerns, Councillor Gareth Dadd defended the council’s spending, noting that the investment in the Filey Brigg site was based on a business case as an "invest-to-save" proposal.
The perspective from rural parishes, however, is markedly different. Independent Councillor Michelle Donohue-Moncrieff, representing Hunmanby and Sherburn, argued that the previous arrangement was an unfair luxury not afforded to her constituents. She stated:
"Unfortunately, the parishes that I represent don't have the bourgeois luxury of an upper tier authority paying for their Christmas trees and their flowers and cutting their grass. They live in the real world. So, I'm really did-ums if posh people in nice parts of the county are going to actually have to pay for it themselves. I really couldn't give a stuff.
So, I am all in favour of people on Scarborough Town Council, Harrogate Town Council paying for this themselves. We cannot have a two-tier system going forward like that."
As the responsibility shifts to the local level, Scarborough Town Council is grappling with how to fund the displays. The historical cost of hiring lights in the town has been approximately £53,000. Independent Councillor Janet Jefferson, who is also President of the Scarborough and District Chamber of Trade and Commerce, has argued that the town must be prepared to invest to remain welcoming for residents and visitors.
However, Labour Councillor Chris Clark has been a vocal critic of the Town Council's proposed £70,000 spend, describing it as an "indefensible excess" when compared to the £18,000 typically spent by similar-sized towns. He argued that the administration was choosing "lights over lives" by prioritising festive displays over community grants that support residents year-round.
Scarborough and Whitby MP Alison Hume Welcomes Government’s “Reset Moment” for SEND Education
Scarborough Motor Home Parking Ban is Unpopular
Scarborough Councillor Welcomes Car Park U-Turn
Whitby Flood Plan Set For Green Light
North Yorkshire Council Corporate Director Moving On
Police Provide Further Update as Investigation Continues into Bridlington Holiday Park Deaths
East Riding Highways Budget Boosted to Tackle Potholes and Support Local Events
Whitby Whalebones to be Replaced with Replicas
Scarborough Athletic Face Derbyshire Test
Yorkshire Dad Dancing Championship to Return to Bridlington
Criticism For Parking Fee Rise in North Yorkshire
New Scarborough Ice Cream Bar Requests Alcohol Licence
Comments
Add a comment