Scarborough Borough Council's planning committee has rejected plans to covert the former Argos building into student accommodation.
In a heated planning meeting councillors raised concerns over parking arrangements and health care provision, but the reason for the rejection came down to the buildings size and outward design.
The plans were to convert the building into student accommodation for the NHS and CU Scarborough. It was hoped the building would accommodate up to 200 students, but there would be no provision for car parking and no right for occupants to obtain on street parking permits.
Councillors on the planning committee said the building was too imposing for the site, it was planned to be five stories while most of the other buildings in the area are three or four stories tall.
A motion to approve the plans failed to gain a majority in a vote. A separate motion to reject the plans was then passed 8 votes to 7.
The motion to reject the plans was put forwards by Councillor Phil Trumper who likened the building design to something from the Eastern Bloc.
Earlier the meeting was briefly adjourned after interventions from the public gallery.
Planning officers has recommended approval of the plans.


Carnaby Holiday Park Deaths: Third Man Arrested As Enquiries Continue
Carnaby Deaths: Families Pay Tribute To Tragic Teens
East Riding Climate Strategy: We Need To Do More
Scarborough Athletic Stay In Play Offs After Hereford Win
Whitby Town Fight Back For Draw in Bamber Bridge Battle
Bridlington Town Six Unbeaten After Latest Victory
Three in Three For Pickering Town Under Heslop
Hornsea Hammered in Rotherham Defeat
Rare Glimpse Inside Scarborough Station’s Clocktower as Restoration Ticks Along
Major Investment Boost for Whitby’s Woodsmith Mine Project
Scarborough Sets Sights on National Stage with 2028 Town of Culture Bid
East Riding Council’s Housing Strategy Sparks Debate Over Ambition and Cost







Comments
Add a comment