Yorkshire Coast councillors have challenged a £1.8m plan to repair Scarborough’s West Pier over concerns that alternative options were not considered.
North Yorkshire Council’s approval of a £1.8m budget for repairs to the harbour wall of Scarborough’s West Pier to extend its lifespan has been called in by councillors who are concerned that alternative options have not been considered.
Members of the authority’s executive committee said they believed “the sheeting under the harbour will last for another 10 years” if repairs went ahead.
However, Coun Janet Jefferson, who represents the Castle division on NYC, which includes the West Pier, said:
“I am calling in this Executive Decision because I do not believe that NYC’s executive were made aware within the legacy harbour project of the alternative option of replacing sheet piling and extending life from 10 to 50 years.”
Speaking to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS), Coun Jefferson said she has been involved with Scarborough’s harbour since 1999, including with the now-defunct Scarborough Borough Council.
The official call-in for the decision was supported by councillors Michelle Donohue-Moncrieff, Stuart Parsons, Phillip Barrett, John McCartney, and Andy Solloway.
Councillor Donohue-Moncrieff said:
"I have supported Cllr Janet Jefferson's call-in of the recent decision by North Yorkshire Council to approve works to extend the life of the piling on Scarborough Harbour for 10 years. The decision has produced more questions than answers relating to future investment into the Harbour.
In particular why is NYC seeking to appropriate a building on West Pier out of the Harbour thereby removing potential future income from the Harbour while at the same time stating that the Harbour Account is overdrawn."
The call-in also highlights potential legal implications following a recent High Court ruling in favour of campaigners who claimed North Yorkshire Council failed to use funds generated by Whitby Harbour to support its maintenance.
Coun Jefferson questioned whether
“the decision to move ring-fenced legacy reserves from Scarborough Harbour into general reserves [is] open to challenge in the light of the Whitby Harbour ruling?”
A report presented to the executive on July 16, when the funding for the repair works was approved, notes that
“the project will be technically underwritten by NYC’s other reserves and the borrowing from the council’s reserves will be repayable to the council when there are sufficient funds available within the Scarborough Harbour account.”
It added:
“Based on the current forecast of the ringfenced account, the repayment is unlikely to happen for some time, and so it is not proposed that interest is charged on the overdrawn balance.”
Coun Jefferson has also asked the council to
“confirm it is progressing new opportunities for income generation and sustainability of the harbour, such as offshore wind energy and the introduction of a boat hoist.”
Council officers said they were developing a report in response to the call-in and a meeting of the corporate and partnerships overview and scrutiny committee is due to discuss the matter in August.
Woman’s Sudden Death Below Whitby Abbey Under Investigation
Scarborough Athletic Make Brid Return
Pickering Town Win in FA Cup Opener
Scarborough Athletic Get Ground Certificate for Temporary Home
Two Arrested Following Drug Warrant in Scarborough
Whitby MP Calls for Consultation on Future of Cliff Lift
Two Arrests After High-Speed Pursuits in Whitby, Malton and Thirsk
North Yorkshire Reports Significant Crime Reduction to be Named Safest County
£313k Funding Boost for Saint Catherine's in Scarborough
Missing Teenager Could be in Whitby
Scarborough WHSmith Store to be Renamed
Yorkshire Coast RNLI Teams in Extensive Search for Missing Swimmer
Comments
Add a comment